There were two ranked-on-ranked matchups in college basketball Tuesday. Both looked great on paper. Neither were competitive on the court.
Final score: Illinois 99, Duke 78
Final score: Tennessee 61, Michigan State 46
I guess a top-15 team handling another top-15 team at home easily isn’t too surprising given the nature of the sport and the way capacity crowds can influence things. It happens. But what happened to Duke on Tuesday was downright shocking.
The Blue Devils were 9.5-point favorites at tip. But they lost by 21 at home.
That makes Illinois the first team to beat Duke by at least 21 points at Cameron Indoor since North Carolina did it in 1989. The Illini also became the first visiting team to win at Cameron Indoor while starting three freshmen since North Carolina did it in 2007.
And then there’s Andrej Stojakovic.
Did you see what he did?
The Illinois senior took 21 shots, made 14 of them and finished with 46 points and six rebounds in 34 minutes. In the process, Stojakovic broke the record for most points ever scored against Duke at Cameron.
Changes are necessary at Duke after Illinois routs home Blue Devils behind Andrej Stojakovic’s historic game
Isaac Trotter

That he did it in a high-profile matchup between two Final Four contenders made it even more impressive. That he also did it in a blowout while Illinois was down two starters, including preseason All-American David Mirkovic, made it unforgettable.
Illinois is up to No. 5 in Wednesday morning’s updated CBS Sports Top 25 And 1 daily college basketball rankings — one spot behind Texas Tech, the 4-0 team that beat Illinois last week. Simply put, I wanted to get Illinois into the top five, and the only way to sensibly do that was to drag undefeated Texas Tech up there with them. So it’s Florida at No. 1, UConn at No. 2, Kansas at No. 3, Texas Tech at No. 4 and Illinois at No. 5 — with Duke all the way down to No. 14 after taking a second loss in five outings.
And is it time to worry about the Blue Devils?
This is the first year Duke coach Jon Scheyer hasn’t had the eventual CBS Sports Player of the Year on his roster since the 2023-24 season. It’s early, sure, but it’s obviously not going well. The Blue Devils are 3-2 with three whatever-wins, a lopsided loss at home to an Illinois team that had already lost at Texas Tech, and another loss to a Michigan State team that just got routed by Tennessee. Duke’s high-priced transfer, John Blackwell, is only averaging 9.0 points while shooting 31.3% from the field. As a team, the Blue Devils are shooting just 28.2% from 3-point range.
College basketball winners, losers: Florida, Houston to clash in 2025 title game rematch; Duke pounded at home
Cameron Salerno

Needless to say, the talent that had Duke as the preseason favorite in the betting markets to win the 2027 NCAA Tournament remains in place, and it’s not even Thanksgiving, so sell all Duke stock at your own risk. But, after five games, the questions about the Blue Devils seem bigger than most anticipated they’d be.